"Pay up or we'll clone your game with AI"


Best Indie Games Newsletter

By Clement • 02 November 2026

Hello Indie Game Fan Reader!

At Steam Indie Connect in South Korea on 27 October, Valve got asked about AI clones to its face and answered on the record. A developer in the room described the emails going around: pay up, or we copy your game with AI and ship it before you do. Tom Giardino of Valve's Steam business team said he was hearing about those cases for the first time, called extortion "closer to an issue for law enforcement rather than one for a gaming platform to resolve", and then added, "If you report such cases to us, we want to look into them and help in whatever way we can."

On AI itself Valve will not budge: "We don't want to be gatekeepers telling developers which tools they should or shouldn't use." Giardino's practical advice to anyone worried about being cloned was to make the clone not worth making, which he framed the same way Valve has always framed piracy. "Rather than relying on a single mechanism that someone can easily copy, you must continue to grow your game by adding features, personality, and creativity that stem from your own perspective as a developer."

On the Next Fest: "We recognize that the trade-off is some low-quality games get exposed. We are fully aware of the situation, and a significant number of people are thinking about how to solve this problem." Giardino pointed out that developers asked for the same filter when Greenlight launched 14 years ago, and again with Steam Direct, and that Valve's answer has not changed: "Rather than limiting developer access, making Steam a smarter and more dynamic platform is the starting point of our philosophy."

While all that was being said, Steam hit a peak of 43.5 million concurrent users, and Digital Sun, the Moonlighter studio, cancelled the public playtest for its next game because it was worried a tool would eat the demo and ship the clone first.

Do you think AI cloning is an issue?(you can reply directly to this email)

Get the list of games from my Fall Showcase.

​Upcoming Games of 2026

SPONSORED

​CLAWSTROPHOBIA - A claw machine rogue-lite deckbuilder where you are trapped in a pit beneath a Japanese subway station, and the only way out is by paying off an insurmountable debt.

Every prize you catch is money toward the next target, which increases in subsequent rounds. The machine is physics-driven and controlled in first-person, so you are lining up the claw yourself and hoping that it successfully catches the prize.

Buy specialty drinks from a vending machine to create your build, adding multipliers to your score or changing how the claw behaves, so find optimal combinations to break the game!

There is a meta-progression system between runs as you continue to unlock new stuff, with a well-crafted horror escape room atmosphere.

​Buy CLAWSTROPHOBIA, out now on Steam.

Indie games of interest

  1. ​World of Anterra - A handcrafted 2D open-world RPG where combat mixes real-time actions with grid positioning. Explore an open world as you go on an epic quest, all in stunning pixel art.
  2. ​Smalland 2: Lost Realms - An open-world survival crafting game at insect scale, where you swim, climb, sneak and forage, where the original was very well received. Sequel has been pushed to 2027.
  3. ​WORLD OF HORROR - A 1-bit Lovecraftian rogue-lite set in a cursed Japanese seaside town. The As Below So Above update brings two new Old Gods, three playable characters and a Scenario Mode.
  4. ​Cairn - A hand-animated solo climbing sim where you plan every hold, piton and bivouac while managing real fatigue. Free Roam now lets you reload any bivouac you reached to try a different line, and the Deep Water Update added three new locations.
  5. ​Shadowstone - A turn-based tactical rogue-lite for up to four, set in the world of Sunderfolk. This is focused on combos, so every ability exists to set up another. Demo available until the end of November.
  6. ​Heroes Never Die - A real-time army-building rogue-lite where you rally troops to a banner and steer them by movement and formation instead of issuing orders. From the developer of Invokyr and Monsters are Coming!
  7. ​KIBORG - A rogue-lite brawler set on a prison planet where you punch, grapple and tear cybernetic cores out, then bolt implants on between runs. The Body Split update adds a second playable character, so co-op players can finally pick different ones.
  8. ​Warhammer Age of Sigmar: Deathmaster - A 2D stealth-action game where you play as a Skaven assassin descending through shifting tunnels, each clan territory with its own rules to learn. Senses run on smell and hearing instead of sight cones so Mark of the Ninja fans, this one's for you.

​Best games of 2026 so far​

News & Articles

  1. ​Peter Molyneux speaks candidly about AI: 'We, as the industry, are pretending we're not using AI, but the reality is, it's almost impossible to code now without using AI' - His argument for why nobody ticks the Steam disclosure box: "if you tick it, you know instantly 12% [of gamers are] gone, and probably a further 18% would probably look at it and go, 'Oh, not for me.'" He predicts that within a year it will be bound so tightly into Unity and Unreal that nobody can extract it.
  2. ​Arkane now has until mid-December to find a buyer as Microsoft extends its deadline - Microsoft agreed to extend the consultation period for Arkane, hope it turns out well for the team.
  3. ​GOTY hopeful Mina the Hollower bought the studio financial stability "for now," while the Shovel Knight devs work on a new 3D game - Yacht Club called Mina make-or-break before launch. It sold over 500,000 copies in two weeks, and Sean Velasco's answer on whether that bought stability was "yes… for now!" Most of the team is now on an unannounced 3D game. 👀 Any guesses?
  4. ​Anthropic orders AI tool Claude to stop remaking video games - A new rule pushed on 27 October reads "Do build original games, games in a genre, and games from the user's own designs and assets. Do not build a recreation of a specific existing game, even if it is renamed or called original", and it cannot be switched off. Anthropic confirmed it.
  5. ​John Romero confirms his axed Xbox game has a new publisher and he's rehired some staff - The team went from 110 people to five and is back up to around 16. Romero kept everything: "We 100% own everything. We own the name, we own all the IP, all the art, all the graphics, the code." On the new deal, which he will not name yet: "they're like 'you make what you want, we're publishing it, we're not going to tell you what to make.' That's the perfect deal."
  6. ​The Mortuary Assistant dev on laying his cancelled Paranormal Activity game to rest, resurrecting it as a Halloween freebie, and a potential return to his biggest game - Brian Clarke spent two years on a Paranormal Activity game, asked Paramount for a small extension to finish QA and ports, and got a no. He and the publisher ended it, Paramount let him keep everything he built, and he stripped the branding and put the slice out free as Playable Archive. His reasoning on shipping it compromised instead: that damage "feels much more damaging to an individual than a big old company".
  7. ​Street Fighter V temporarily delisted and online functions turned off due to issues caused by last week's PHP security flaw - Capcom pulled the game from sale on Steam and PlayStation in stages and killed online while it patches. Existing owners can still play offline. Still unavailable on Steam as of writing
  8. ​32-year-old "ellipsoid" horror game Ecstatica gets a PC re-release today, showing us an alternative timeline in which polygonal 3D never became dominant - Ecstatica built its whole world out of volumetric ellipsoids rather than polygons. WEIRD and worth a look

Indie Game of the Week

​Blood West - A stealth-first immersive sim in a cursed Old West, where you play as an undead gunslinger exploring three open maps of mines, swamps and canyons. Ammo is scarce and enemies hit hard, so you creep with a bow and throwing knives and save the revolver for when sh*t hits the fan.

Death costs you a permanent stat penalty until you buy it back at a shrine, but you can use trinkets to create a build of sorts, with an excellently one throwback look.

Get it at 50% off.

Poll!

Do you have any feedback or comments? You can reply directly to this email and I'll see it! Let me know your thoughts on the news and games above, as well an anything you would like to see!

My name is Clement and I love indie games! As such, I make videos on indie games big and small, highlighting my favorites & supporting developers so that they can make more cool stuff.

Support my work on Patreon!

Best Indie Games

Covering all things indie games! https://www.youtube.com/c/ClemmyGames

Read more from Best Indie Games

Best Indie Games Newsletter By Clement • 10 November 2026 Hello Indie Game Fan Reader! On 3 November itch.io posted five words on Bluesky: Just deleted a couple terabytes of ai slop. The follow-up was more blunt. "Just because you can upload 10 terabytes of poorly optimized ai generated models doesn't mean you should upload 10 terabytes of poorly optimized ai generated models," and, as a reminder, they have had an AI spam clause in their quality guidelines for over two years. itch.io says the...

Best Indie Games Newsletter By Clement • 25 October 2026 Hello Indie Game Fan Reader! On 21 October, BioWare posted its own closing statement. EA is shutting the studio down after more than 30 years and ending early development on the next Mass Effect game, internally titled Mass Effect Universe. It is part of a cut of roughly 400 jobs, about 3% of EA's staff, with around 50 of those at BioWare itself. "Baldur's Gate. Neverwinter Nights. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. Dragon Age....

Best Indie Games Newsletter By Clement • 18 October 2026 Hello Indie Game Fan Reader! Freehold Games and Kitfox announced on 15 October that Caves of Qud is getting its first expansion, Diaspora, on 9 December for $14.99. So far, so normal, right? Wrong. Diaspora is launching into Early Access, which nobody has done with DLC on Steam before. The base game itself spent nine years in Early Access before 1.0 in 2024 and it is now going straight back in. Game Developer reported that Valve had to...